Table of Contents
There are 5 signs you should be looking for when it’s time to move on from your current psychiatry billing company. The ones you should consider a flag in the flag when your denial rate goes up to 8%+, when your A R consistently goes over 60 to 90+ days, when your biller doesn’t know what behavioral health CPT codes are, when you’re not getting reporting from them on a monthly basis and when they’re unable to give you a clear and concise answer on price and performance. If you check three of these boxes, you are not receiving money you already earned.
Here’s the full breakdown and what you should expect instead.
5 Signs Your Billing Company Isn't Working
Finding out that your medical billing company is underperforming usually happens after you’ve already lost thousands in uncollected revenue. If you notice any of the following red flags, it’s a clear sign that your current partner is costing you more than they are worth.
Denial Rates Are Climbing
A/R Is Aging Past Due
Lack of Behavioral Specialization
No Proactive Communication
Hidden Pricing and Performance
Sign 1: Your Denial Rate Is Climbing or Stuck Above Benchmark
Denial rates in behavioral health average 16 to 20% at generalist billing companies. A specialized behavioral health RCM partner should be holding your denial rate under 8% and moving it toward 5% with systematic denial prevention.
If your denial rate is rising, staying flat above 10%, or if you simply don’t know what it is, that last point is its own problem your billing company isn’t managing denials. They’re processing claims.
Watch for these patterns:
- Same denial codes (CO-11, CO-16, CO-B7) appearing month after month with no root cause fix
- Denied claims sitting in a queue past 30 days without active follow-up
- No monthly denial trend report broken down by payer and CARC code
A billing company that cannot tell you your denial rate by payer is not managing your revenue cycle. It’s submitting claims and hoping.
How much revenue did you lose to denials this month?
Stop letting insurance companies keep what you earned. In just one call, we’ll dive into your current AR and denial rates to pinpoint exactly where your cash flow is leaking.
Sign 2: Your AR Is Consistently Aging Past 60 to 90 Days
AR over 90 days should represent less than 10% of your total outstanding balance. When it creeps above 15% or when you see claims sitting at 120 days without resolution you have a follow-up failure, not a payer problem.
The most common cause is a billing company managing too many specialties across too many clients, with no systematic AR prioritization. High-dollar denied psychiatry claims age silently while smaller claims get worked.
Signs this is happening:
- You ask about a specific unpaid claim and it takes days to get an answer
- Your biller can’t explain why a claim is unpaid beyond “it’s pending”
- Write-offs are increasing without clear documentation of why claims were closed
Every day a claim ages past 90 days, the probability of full recovery decreases. Timely filing windows close. And the revenue is permanently gone.
Sign 3: Your Billing Company Doesn't Specialize in Behavioral Health
This is the most expensive sign and the hardest to see until you’re deep in it.
Behavioral health billing is not general medical billing with different codes. Psychiatry requires E/M and psychotherapy add-on code combinations with modifier 25. It requires MBHO carve-out routing to Optum Behavioral Health, Carelon, or Magellan, not the base commercial plan. It requires time-based CPT documentation precision.
Generalist billers routinely miss all three:
- Billing 99213 when 99214 is clearly supported systematic undercoding that adds up to $20,000+ annually per provider
- Submitting to Aetna instead of Evernorth CO-4 denials on every Evernorth-carved patient until someone catches it
- Missing modifier 25 on combined E/M + add-on visits CO-97 bundling denials
Does your billing company have credentialing and payer enrollment support that includes MBHO carve-out enrollment? Do they understand the difference between 90833 and 90836? If the answer to either question is unclear, specialization is not there.
Sign 4: You Receive No Proactive Reporting or Communication
A billing company should tell you when something is wrong before you ask. If your primary experience is submitting a support ticket to find out why a payer hasn’t paid in 90 days, the relationship is backwards.
You should be receiving, at minimum:
- Weekly: Clean claim submission confirmation and any rejections flagged
- Monthly: Denial rate by payer and CARC code, days in AR, net collection rate
- Quarterly: Trend analysis are numbers improving, declining, or stagnant?
If the last time you received an unsolicited performance update was when you signed the contract, your billing company is reactive, not proactive. You’re managing them instead of them managing your revenue.
Sign 5: Pricing and Performance Are Not Transparent
You should know exactly what you’re paying and exactly what you’re getting for it. If your billing agreement is a percentage of collections but you cannot independently verify your collection rate, your pricing model has no accountability mechanism.
Red flags:
- No dashboard or portal access to your own AR and denial data
- Vague answers when you ask about first-pass acceptance rate or net collection rate
- Hidden fees for credentialing, prior authorization, or telehealth billing that weren’t in the original quote
Transparent billing partnerships provide independent dashboard access to your data. Your performance numbers belong to you not locked inside your vendor’s system.
What Should Your Denial Rate Actually Be?
| Metric | Industry Benchmark |
|---|---|
| Average denial rate (generalist billing company) | 16 to 20% |
| Average denial rate (behavioral health-specific RCM) | 8 to 12% |
| Target with denial prevention workflow | Under 5% |
| AR over 90 days (healthy practice) | Under 10% of total AR |
| Net collection rate (strong performance) | 95% or higher |
These are industry benchmark ranges, not guarantees. Your actual numbers depend on payer mix, specialty, and documentation quality. But if your current vendor cannot tell you where you fall relative to these ranges that is the problem.
Is Switching Easier Than You Think?
Yes, if it’s handled correctly.
The fear of switching billing companies is almost always about disruption. The reality is that a well-managed transition creates no gap in claims processing. Here’s how it works with BehavioralProz:
- Parallel-run setup: Your new billing workflow is configured while your current vendor continues submitting no claims stop mid-cycle
- Credentialing continuity: We audit your active payer enrollments and flag any gaps before go-live, not after
- 30-day overlap review: We run a side-by-side comparison of the first month’s claims performance against your previous baseline
- No disruption to patients: Patients see nothing change on their end
Most practices are fully operational under the new workflow within 4 to 6 weeks of signing. The disruption is minimal. The alternative of staying with a vendor that’s losing you revenue is not.
Old Billing Company vs. Specialized Behavioral Health Partner
| Old Billing Company Pain Point | What a Specialized Partner Does Instead |
|---|---|
| Denial rate above 10%, no root cause tracking | Denial trend reports by CARC code monthly; root cause fixed within the billing cycle |
| AR aging past 90 days with no follow-up | Defined follow-up cadence at Day 30, 45, and 60; high-dollar claims escalated at Day 15 |
| Generalist coding — wrong CPT codes, missed add-ons | Behavioral health CPT expertise: E/M + add-on, time-based codes, MBHO routing |
| No proactive reporting or communication | Weekly claim confirmations, monthly KPI reports, quarterly trend analysis |
| Hidden fees, no dashboard access | Transparent pricing, independent dashboard access, performance data belongs to you |
Get an honest look at your current denial rate.
Think your billing team is doing “fine”? Let’s verify it. We will analyze your revenue cycle and give you a transparent, zero-obligation assessment of whether your practice could be making significantly more.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good denial rate for a psychiatry practice?
A well-managed psychiatry billing operation should target a denial rate under 8%, with best-in-class practices achieving under 5%. The behavioral health industry average at generalist billing companies runs 16 to 20% the gap between those numbers is recoverable revenue.
How do I know if my billing company is underperforming?
Ask for three numbers: your current denial rate by payer, your AR over 90 days as a percentage of total AR, and your net collection rate. If your billing company cannot provide all three within 24 hours, that is the answer.
Will switching billing companies disrupt my current claims?
Not if the transition is managed in parallel. A reputable RCM partner configures the new billing workflow while your current vendor continues running, so no claims gap occurs during transition.
How long does it take to switch RCM vendors?
Most practices are fully operational with a new billing partner within 4 to 6 weeks of signing including EHR integration, payer verification, and go-live.
What should I look for in a behavioral health billing partner?
Behavioral health specialization (not general medical), MBHO carve-out enrollment expertise, time-based CPT code fluency, independent reporting access, and a defined denial management workflow with a follow-up SLA.